I'm afraid this has to be settled in Super Smash Brothers Brawl. We'll put CPU-controlled Mario and CPU-controlled Sonic onto the Final Destination stage with no items and see who wins. The results of the match will be indisputable. Then, the fans of the losing mascot must commit suicide, because there is nothing more important or sacred than one imaginary character's superiority over another.

Hawk
I'm afraid this has to be settled in Super Smash Brothers Brawl. We'll put CPU-controlled Mario and CPU-controlled Sonic onto the Final Destination stage with no items and see who wins. The results of the match will be indisputable. Then, the fans of the losing mascot must commit suicide, because there is nothing more important or sacred than one imaginary character's superiority over another.

So, just like our forefathers settled their differences.


I think that pacman would be, because he's one of the original games characters. For the sake of just saying my favourite character, I'll also suggest Kirby.

Sonic Vs. Mario

Phoenix Write beats them both.

therealtj

Sonic Vs. Mario

Phoenix Write beats them both.

I OBJECT!

bluebot092

therealtj

Sonic Vs. Mario

Phoenix Write beats them both.

I OBJECT!

No.

bluebot092

therealtj

Sonic Vs. Mario

Phoenix Write beats them both.

I OBJECT!

Objection!
That should be 'Objection!' and 'Wright' not 'Write'.
If you spell his name wrong at least spell it right.
See, it's a pun, because his name is meant to be like 'right' and I alluded to this in a phrase, 'If you're going to say it say it right' which is quite funny even if I say so myself...

Hawk
I'm afraid this has to be settled in Super Smash Brothers Brawl. We'll put CPU-controlled Mario and CPU-controlled Sonic onto the Final Destination stage with no items and see who wins. The results of the match will be indisputable. Then, the fans of the losing mascot must commit suicide, because there is nothing more important or sacred than one imaginary character's superiority over another.

Done; multiple times, multiple modes (timed, stock, various amounts of time and stock). Except I used battlefield, because I feel it's a more accurate neutral stage than FD.

The winner, 8 out of 10: Mario.

Now, according to the Hawker treaty, Sonic fans must now commit suicide; sorry.

Luckily, no specific mode of suicide has been specified. I'm going to immediately get to work on old-aging myself to death.

Ah, wait. We need video proof first. We can't just take your word for it.

I'm not saying you're a liar. Mario fans could easily have kidnapped you and altered your memories.

Yeah, I had the same results too when I tried it last night. Mario's victories outnumbered Sonic's 2 to 1 on Final Destination. Just for kicks I tried pairing them up on Green Hills and the Mushroom Kingdom. Sonic won the single Green Hills fight, but lost terribly on the two Mushroom Kingdom matches, due to him killing himself so much.

But like Custard Trout mentions, these victories could be tainted. The entire time I was praying to the President of Nintendo through the microphone on my DS, while kneeling on a Power Pad.

That one Space Invader.

1:Omnipresence.
2:A master floater.
3:You explode if you touch it.
4:Can purchase GO!, but chooses not to.
5:Sharper than Sonic.
6:Wider than mario.
7:My list is the longest.

I think the ultimate gaming mascot is Pacman.

1. He's the most recognizable video game character, even a pie missing a slice looks like pacman. he's everywhere. (i'm the reason the pie is missing a slice)
2. The game was simple yet challenging.
3.Champions are crowned in the name of pacman.
4. Pacman came before Sonic and Mario.

Also, I tried the sonic mario cpu thing. I think nintendo secretly upped mario's stats, but its only noticable around sonic. whenever i put the two together (they're both on cpu level 9) sonic just stands around using his shield and occasionally killing himself while mario attacks him like a raging beast. Nope, Nintendo's not one to hold a grudge at all. No rubbing it into Sega's face for them, no siree.