Well the first one was good because although it wasn't original, it was something that hasn't been done in a long time to suit the audience it was aimed at. I mean the last musical anything I enjoyed was Lion King and I was a lot younger then but I truly loved Dr. Horrible not just for the show it's self but the songs. Even if it is a total cash-cow I'll forgive it if it can give me a few more songs to get stuck in my head :-D