Here, the guy needs to be saying a real word, or better yet an actual sentence, but one unrelated to what the cat said.
Like "Penguins aren't always so greasy in here."
The don't have the cat reply, because what he said is obviously not related to what the cat said, so we don't need it pointing out.
Then keep the caption the same.
Final note- the cat should be saying all your cushion are belong to us, not all your cushions belong to me, in order to capture the spirit of all your base are belong to us.
